Just got it and opened it, it was as if there was no product inside. Its black is faint. At the same time, when I tried to remove it, it wouldn't come off at all, even though I use a very good makeup remover that I have never had any issues with in the past. I'm trying to find a good affordable eyeliner and... I think it's a product category that you definitely have to spend 10-15+ euros on to be good because in the end, you're giving less like me now and throwing your money in the trash. 0 out of 0.